GRR

Video: M3 vs. M5 vs. JDM heroes

19th January 2021
Laura Thomson

Pick a car – any car. Well, pick from a BMW M3, M5, 330i, Subaru Legacy, Toyota Aristo or a Honda Accord R. Tough decision, right? Luckily, the Best Motoring series (where Japanese racers drive new cars flat-out together) has made the decision for us, 20 years ago when the above models were fresh out the box. But you’ll have to watch the video to find out the victor – and does it match our modern perception?

From the then-$114,000 E39 M5 with its 5.0-litre 400PS V8 to the 3.0-litre 280PS Turbo L6 Aristo, which at $38,000 is a mere fraction of its competitor, this video pits expensive German engineering against its more affordable Japanese counterparts. The $66,000 343PS straight-six-powered E46 M3 lines up against the $23,000 2.0-litre, 280PS Legacy B4RSK, while a regular E46 330i and the Accord EURO-R are the affordable options of their respective families.

On a wet Japanese circuit, the drivers let loose, putting the cars through their paces in a brilliant battle. We’re not going to spoil the fun for you, so set aside 10 minutes this morning and live your noughties sports car dreams.

Welcome to Goodwood Elevenses, a mid-morning helping of motoring-related amusement to help break up your day. Watch the last video: McRae flat‑out in testing

  • elevenses

  • video

  • JDM

  • M3

  • M5

  • BMW

  • E46

  • E39

  • Subaru

  • Honda

  • Legacy

  • Accord

Goodwood Revival Racing Experience

2025 DATES NOW LIVE
https://www.goodwood.com/globalassets/hero-videos/experiences/motor-circuit/goodwood-revival-racing-online-video-cutter.com.mp4
e46-m3-e39-m5-jdm-best-motoring-track-battle-video-goodwood-19012021.jpg

News

Video: M3 vs. M5 vs. JDM heroes

19th January 2021

best-bmw-m3-main2-goodwood-06032021.jpg

News

Which BMW M3 would you buy? | Thank Frankel it’s Friday

06th April 2021

best-bmw-m-cars-list-main-06012022.jpg

News

The 11 best BMW M cars ever

06th January 2022

elevenses-bmw-e46-m3-onboard.jpg

Historic

Video: This BMW E46 M3 looks like the perfect track car

09th December 2022

p90492732_highres_the-all-new-bmw-m3-c.jpg

News

2023 BMW M3 CS is the most powerful M3 ever

25th January 2023

bmw-engined-cars-main-2.jpg

News

7 cars you didn’t know have BMW engines

12th October 2022

elevenses-bmw-m3-nurburgring.jpg

Modern

Video: Onboard BMW M3 GTS vs M5 Nürburgring battle

09th May 2023

bmw-m5-e39-e60-comparison-main-goodwood-23102019.jpg

News

Battle of the M5s: E39 vs. E60

23rd October 2019